Food trends in London move with exhausting speed. One month you are paying thirty quid for fermented cabbage foam, the next you are standing in a car park waiting for a sourdough focaccia slice. But every so often a kitchen opens that ignores the noise entirely and looks backward to move forward. Enter B. Penhale, the new Smithfield restaurant from the team behind Camille.
If you think you know British dining because you have eaten a mediocre Sunday roast at a local boozer, think again. This place strips away the micro-herbs and tweezers, leaning hard into trotters, pigeon pie, and the kind of offal your grandfather probably ate without making a performance out of it.
The Smithfield Spirit and the Betty Penhale Connection
Location matters in the restaurant business. It dictates your ingredient suppliers, your clientele, and your emotional resonance. Situated at 57 West Smithfield, B. Penhale occupies the Grade II-listed former home of Club Gascon. More importantly, it sits right on the doorstep of Smithfield Market. That historic meat market is in the bones of this venture.
Chef patron Elliot Hashtroudi named the place after his grandmother, Betty Penhale. Her family history is deeply entwined with Smithfield, where his maternal great-grandmother worked as a butcher. That is not just marketing boilerplate. It shapes every single plate coming out of the kitchen. Hashtroudi cut his teeth at Padella, Trullo, and St John before taking the culinary world by storm at Camille in Borough Market. When Time Out crowned Camille the best restaurant in London, people took notice.
Yet B. Penhale feels distinct from its famous sister. It avoids replicating a Parisian bistro template and leans into a gritty, deeply personal exploration of British regional cooking.
Why Offal and Pigeon Pie Are Winning Back London
For decades, British food suffered from a collective national cringe. We exported our best ingredients and apologized for our traditional pies, puddings, and braises. We tried too hard to be French or Italian.
B. Penhale rejects that apology. The menu proudly features offal, trotters, and game. This approach is not a cheap gimmick designed for Instagram shock value. It is practical, sustainable, and frankly, delicious. Whole-carcass butchery requires skill. It forces a kitchen to respect every part of the animal rather than just trimming off the expensive fillets and tossing the rest.
When you order a pigeon pie here, you are getting rich, iron-heavy game encased in pastry that actually tastes like butter rather than cardboard. Trotters arrive unctuous, sticky, and deeply savory. These are dishes born from working-class resourcefulness, elevated through precise technique without losing their soul.
Critics who turn their noses up at offal miss the point entirely. Muscle meat is easy. Anyone can grill a steak. Transforming tongue, heart, and trotters into something transcendent separates true cookery from assembly-line hospitality.
The Wine List and the Victorian Spirit
A great meal falls apart if the glass in your hand fights the plate in front of you. Head of wine Max Hancock built a drink list that matches the kitchen's historical curiosity. Instead of defaulting to standard Burgundy or Rioja, the cellar focuses heavily on British winemakers crafting wine both in the British Isles and abroad.
Even more fascinating is the nod to history. Part of the list borrows inspiration from what Victorian Britain actually drank. It sounds eccentric on paper, but in practice, it anchors the entire dining room in a specific time and place. You are drinking history, not just fermented grape juice.
What Other New Openings Miss
Most modern restaurant launches rely on a predictable playbook. Neon signage, small plates designed to arrive at random intervals, and loud house music make conversation impossible. You leave hungry and poorer.
B. Penhale takes a different path. It respects the appetite. It respects the room, which honors the building's rich past, including its days as a Lyon's Tea House. You sit down, you eat substantial food, and you drink properly.
If you want to understand where contemporary London dining is heading, stop looking at TikTok-fueled pop-ups. Look at the places willing to dig into our culinary archive, dust off the offal, and serve a proper pie with zero irony.
Book a table for dinner early in the week. Order the cuts everyone else ignores. Taste what happens when a kitchen stops trying to please everyone and focuses entirely on what is real.